When I was brainstorming cake flavors for my sister’s birthday the first idea that crossed my mind was actually a chocolate chip cookie cake. She and my mom joke that when they went on college tours together they rated the schools based on the quality of the cookies sold in their dining hall. I wanted something a little more special though, so I decided on a chocolate mint cake. She loves mint in any fashion, with or without chocolate. So I began searching for recipes. I had a picture of one in my mind – rich chocolate cake layers flavored with peppermint extract, with some sort of white-mint icing layered in between. However, I was disappointed time and time again by the recipes I found, which seemed more focused on the chocolate than the mint. Finally I settled on this recipe, a chocolate cake with a mint filling and a thick chocolate glaze. Yes, I know it is very focused on the chocolate but it was the most promising recipe I found.
The December issue of Bon Appetit arrived the week after I baked this cake. And there, smack dab on the cover, was the cake I had been imagining – a four layer devil’s food cake with chocolate ganache AND white chocolate filling, slathered with peppermint frosting. As soon as I saw it I started singing the Alanis Morissette song “Ironic” (spare me the lecture about musical taste please… I can’t help it that I was a child of the 90s). Anyhow, now I have a serious case of cake envy. Here it is. Doesn’t it look to die for? Feel free to skip the rest of this and go for that as long as you let me know how it turns out.
Still reading? Ok. The best part of this recipe for me was the discovery of the chocolate bar I chopped up to place in the cake batter in place of the chocolate chips. I bought it on a whim at Whole Foods in an attempt to make the cake minty-er. It had just the right balance of mint, chocolate, and crunch. Maybe I was so busy eating the leftover scraps of it that I overcooked the cake. Those of you who have eaten my baked goods before know that I always err on the side of underbaking, so this was quite unusual for me. Suffice it to say 65 minutes was waaaay to long for this particular recipe. I’d start checking it after 45 minutes. The other part that just didn’t work for me was the milk chocolate layered in the middle of the cake. I realize that this amount of dark chocolate is too much for some people. In that case, choose another cake. I just didn’t like combining that tinny flavor of milk chocolate (and I used good quality bars) with the richness of the bittersweet glaze. The glaze however, was awesome, and the cake would have been fine if it hadn’t been dry due to my error. If I tried it again I would either swap out the milk chocolate for dark in the filling, make extra glaze and use that in the middle, or just skip the filling altogether.
It was pretty though… Not a total flop, I suppose! Sorry I didn’t get any photos of the inside. We took it with us to Pop’s. They were nice enough to cut and plate it for all 20-something of us. I felt too guilty to ask to take pictures and the lighting was terrible at our table.
